When The Man Up Speech Isn’t Enough

There’s a great scene in the movie Any Given Sunday in which Al Pacino (who plays an on the hot seat head coach) gives a pre-game speech to his team before the last and most important game of the year.  All season he has been trying to bring the team together and help a young QB forced into action become a leader.  It’s gone poorly.  But now the veteran QB has returned from injury and Pacino knows this game and season is all on the line.

The speech actually has a lot of deep stuff in it (and a bad word or two) and there is something about it that makes you want to go to battle.  But what I love the most about the scene comes at the very end.  As Pacino closes he challenges the the team.  He says we can win or lose, live or die.  Then he says, “Now what are you going to do?!”  The locker room goes crazy.  Men are going nuts they are so fired up. They’re ready to rush into battle. Except for the two most veteran players.  You know why?  Because they’d been there before.  And they knew the cost.  I realized watching that scene that they were the real men.

I once got to spend 4 days at a John Eldredge Wild at Heart “boot camp.”  It was in Colorado at a Young Life Property in the mountains.  In the instructions to get there it said, “Rent a 4 wheel drive vehicle from the airport.  You will probably need it”.  What could be more “man” than that.

It was an incredible weekend.  Eldredge and his friends that led the retreat did not disappoint.  We looked at our wounds and talked about how we were created as men.

Now you would think that the message the last day would have been something like, “Now go out and change the world” or, “Take action now!  Change everything!”  But you know what they said about 10 different ways? “Do NOT rush the field.”  In other words move cautiously.  Dig deep.  Go slow and steady.  God has shown you some stuff.  Take it back and chew on it.

The church is scared when it comes to the marriage.  The reality is all around them. The writing is on the wall and the season is coming to the end.  Masculinity as we were created to have it is in real trouble.  I mean 4th and goal trouble.  Men are failing to lead. They are not getting married.  Some are marrying other men.  There are more and more unmarried people that probably shouldn’t be.  Men are either weak, ruled by women, or living in extended adolescence. And it seems no matter what we do the trend continues.

Lots of things have contributed to it.  The feminist movement, lives that are too comfortable and at our fingertips – including sexual immorality, and a huge amount of fatherlessness that just continues to speed up the cycle.

We’ve tried to answer it with books and rallies. We got together to make promises.  We asked young men (and women) to wait for true love.  We kissed dating goodbye. The result?  It’s worse now than ever.  Did we actually think that we could slogan ourselves to victory?

The latest attempt to fix all of this are the “Man Up” pastors.  These guys are fired up.  A lot of them are angry. They know all the problems and causes inside and out and they rail against them.  All the problems are apparently men’s fault. They know that men need to step up and they are ready to challenge us to do it.  But here’s the problem.  If you rush the field, if you get fired up and head out, if you spend all of your energy in the first three minutes of the game, you’re going to get your tail kicked when you get out there.

What does this have to do with singleness?  Everything!

It’s a mess out there as a single guy.  But if you don’t know who you are as a man it’s complete disaster.  Most of us have never been taught what to do with women and most of what we have been taught is wrong.  And being told to man up is not going to cut it. The pre-game speech (read sermon) is not enough.  We need the right practice, the right in game coaching and the some of us need a whole new playbook.  We need veteran leadership.

This is all prologue really.  I’m going to write more on this asap.  I promise it’s going somewhere.  But for today, let me ask you a couple of questions.  What does man up mean to you? Do you want to be fired up or are you willing to be built up?

8 thoughts on “When The Man Up Speech Isn’t Enough

  1. Great post. What does man up mean to me? It means carefully examine the situation, making bible based decisions, and taking action with conviction in a timely manner. Man up is standing for righteousness, honoring God, respecting yourself and others.

  2. “Man Up” is the phrase that is the one thing since accepting Christ. Working, studying, and living a life worthy of His favor….that I DON’T like. I don’t like how it is assumed on all levels that somehow, even in the church…..somehow I need “intense” accountability while women who just show up to a random Sunday sermon are deemed “deserving” of a husband, a boyfriend, or even just a date. I don’t like the phrase “Man Up” because it projects some stereotypes of men…we have to be “confident” when scripture tells us we are to “be only confident in the Lord” (Phil 4:13). What about what do real men do today? Do they only play contact sports? Are they only good at math? Do they major in the hard sciences? Do they hate Mozart and love to shoot guns? Do they leave Jane Austen to the chicks? Did jesus play tackle football? Does the Bible say anything about this? No? The we as Christian men need to stop fobbing all of this off as “Manning Up” lest the Word of God rebuke you and prove you to be a liar (Prov. 30:5-6).

    The connotations bother me. Yes, I do go to my men’s fellowship still. Yes, I do not regret my choice for Christ. I think being a man in church needs to be re-examined on many levels….from the pulpit, the perspective of our Christian sisters, and other factors.

    I don’t like the phrase. I don’t like how it has spread like “wildfire” throughout the Christian faith (all denominations) and guess what….marriage is still on the decline. People are still hurting in this area, and we still have (nationally) declining numbers. This phrase isn’t “helping” in my opinion, and short walk with The Savior.

    Good post Justin

  3. Pingback: Attraction Before Rescue | More Than Don't Have Sex

  4. Pingback: Don’t Believe The Lies | More Than Don't Have Sex

  5. Pingback: If Only Christian Men Would Ask Us Out | More Than Don't Have Sex

  6. Pingback: Why It Doesn’t Matter If You Would “Treat Her Better” | More Than Don't Have Sex

  7. Pingback: It’s Time To “People Up” | More Than Don't Have Sex

  8. Pingback: Chasing Vs. Pursuing | More Than Don't Have Sex

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s